Abstract AlgebraSylow TheoremsSome Applications of the Sylow Theorems
Groups of Order pq
After seeing that groups of order pq are never simple, we now study their structure more precisely. Let p and q be primes with p>q. The Sylow p-subgroup is forced to be normal, and the remaining question is how a subgroup of order q acts on it by conjugation. In this lesson, the focus keyword is groups of order pq. The main result says that such a group is either cyclic or a nonabelian semidirect product, and the nonabelian case can occur only when q divides p−1.
:::definition[Group of Order pq]
Let p and q be prime integers with p>q. A group of order pq is a finite group G such that ∣G∣=pq.
:::
:::theorem
Let G be a group of order pq, where p and q are prime integers with p>q. Then the Sylow p-subgroup of G is normal.
:::
:::proof
Given that G is a group of order pq, where p and q are prime integers with p>q.
To prove that the Sylow p-subgroup of G is normal.
Let np be the number of Sylow p-subgroups of G. By Sylow's third theorem,
npnp≡1(modp),∣q.
Thus np=1 or np=q. Since q<p, the congruence q≡1(modp) is impossible. Therefore
np=1.
The unique Sylow p-subgroup is normal.
Hence the Sylow p-subgroup of G is normal.
□
:::
:::theorem
Let G be a group of order pq, where p and q are prime integers with p>q. If q∤(p−1), then G is cyclic.
:::
:::proof
Given that G is a group of order pq, p>q, and q∤(p−1).
To prove that G is cyclic.
By the preceding theorem, the Sylow p-subgroup P is normal in G. By Cauchy's theorem, choose a∈G of order q, and let Q=⟨a⟩. Also choose b∈P with P=⟨b⟩.
Since P is normal, conjugation by a induces an automorphism of P. Therefore there exists an integer r such that
a−1ba=br.
Because aq=e, applying this conjugation q times gives
b=brq.
Thus
rq≡1(modp).
If the action is nontrivial, then r has order q in (Z/pZ)×, whose order is p−1. Hence q∣(p−1), contradicting the hypothesis.
Therefore the action is trivial, so a commutes with b. Since G=PQ, P and Q are cyclic of relatively prime orders and commute elementwise. Thus
G≅P×Q≅Cp×Cq≅Cpq.
Hence G is cyclic.
□
:::
This preview shows how the arithmetic condition q∣(p−1) controls groups of order pq when p>q. Choose two primes or use a preset from the examples and exercises. The Sylow p-subgroup is always normal, so the remaining question is whether a subgroup of order q can act nontrivially on Cp. When q∤(p−1), no nontrivial action exists and every group of order pq is cyclic.
:::scientific-preview[Order pq Structure Explorer]
Groups of Order pq | BMLabs | Sylow Theorems | BMLabs Mathematics | BMLabs Mathematics
Visual Learning UG
Abstract Algebra · Sylow Theorems
Groups of Order pq
Learn Groups of Order pq. This page develops the main mathematical ideas in a clear sequence.
After seeing that groups of order pq are never simple, we now study their structure more precisely. Let p and q be primes with p>q. The Sylow p-subgroup is forced to be normal, and the remaining question is how a subgroup of order q acts on it by conjugation. In this lesson, the focus keyword is groups of order pq. The main result says that such a group is either cyclic or a nonabelian semidirect product, and the nonabelian case can occur only when q divides p−1.
Core definition02
Group of Order pq
Let p and q be prime integers with p>q. A group of order pq is a finite group G such that ∣G∣=pq.
Key result03
Let G be a group of order pq, where p and q are prime integers with p>q. Then the Sylow p-subgroup of G is normal.
Reasoning pathway04
Given that G is a group of order pq, where p and q are prime integers with p>q.
To prove that the Sylow p-subgroup of G is normal.
Let np be the number of Sylow p-subgroups of G. By Sylow's third theorem,
npnp≡1(modp),∣q.
Thus np=1 or np=q. Since q<p, the congruence q≡1(modp) is impossible. Therefore
np=1.
The unique Sylow p-subgroup is normal.
Hence the Sylow p-subgroup of G is normal.
□
Key result05
Let G be a group of order pq, where p and q are prime integers with p>q. If q∤(p−1), then G is cyclic.
Reasoning pathway06
Given that G is a group of order pq, p>q, and q∤(p−1).
To prove that G is cyclic.
By the preceding theorem, the Sylow p-subgroup P is normal in G. By Cauchy's theorem, choose a∈G of order q, and let Q=⟨a⟩. Also choose b∈P with P=⟨b⟩.
Since P is normal, conjugation by a induces an automorphism of P. Therefore there exists an integer r such that
a−1ba=br.
Because aq=e, applying this conjugation q times gives
b=brq.
Thus
rq≡1(modp).
If the action is nontrivial, then r has order q in (Z/pZ)×, whose order is p−1. Hence q∣(p−1), contradicting the hypothesis.
Therefore the action is trivial, so a commutes with b. Since G=PQ, P and Q are cyclic of relatively prime orders and commute elementwise. Thus
G≅P×Q≅Cp×Cq≅Cpq.
Hence G is cyclic.
□
This preview shows how the arithmetic condition q∣(p−1) controls groups of order pq when p>q. Choose two primes or use a preset from the examples and exercises. The Sylow p-subgroup is always normal, so the remaining question is whether a subgroup of order q can act nontrivially on Cp. When q∤(p−1), no nontrivial action exists and every group of order pq is cyclic.
Visual laboratory
Order pq Structure Explorer
ORDER PQ STRUCTURE EXPLORER
Dynamic Sandbox
Initializing Workspace
The normal Sylow p-subgroup supplies the cyclic factor Cp. The divisibility test q∣(p−1) decides whether a subgroup of order q can act nontrivially on it.
This calculator performs the cyclicity criterion for groups of order pq. Enter primes with p>q, and it checks normality of the Sylow p-subgroup and the divisibility condition q∣(p−1). The output tells you whether every group of order pq must be cyclic or whether a nonabelian semidirect product is allowed. Try the defaults for order 21, then compare orders 35, 65, and 77.
Interactive calculator
pq Cyclicity Criterion Calculator
PQ CYCLICITY CRITERION CALCULATOR
Initializing Workspace
The calculator reports what this theorem can force from the order alone. When the nonabelian route is allowed, a separate construction or classification argument is needed to decide which groups actually occur.
Key result12
Let G be a group of order pq, where p and q are prime integers with p>q. If G is not cyclic, then q∣(p−1).
Reasoning pathway13
Given that G is a noncyclic group of order pq, where p>q.
To prove that q∣(p−1).
Let P=⟨b⟩ be the normal Sylow p-subgroup of G, and let Q=⟨a⟩ be a Sylow q-subgroup. Since P is normal, conjugation by a gives an automorphism of P. Thus
a−1ba=br
for some integer r.
If r≡1(modp), then a commutes with b, so G≅Cp×Cq≅Cpq, contrary to the hypothesis that G is noncyclic. Therefore r≡1(modp).
Since aq=e, we get
rq≡1(modp).
Hence the residue class of r has order q in the group (Z/pZ)×. Since this group has order p−1, Lagrange's theorem gives
q∣(p−1).
Hence the noncyclic case can occur only when q∣(p−1).
□
Guided example14
Every group of order 15 is cyclic.
Complete solution15
Let ∣G∣=15=3⋅5. Here p=5 and q=3. Since
3∤4,
the cyclic criterion applies. Therefore every group of order 15 is cyclic.
Alternatively, n5≡1(mod5) and n5∣3, so n5=1. Also n3≡1(mod3) and n3∣5, so n3=1. The two normal cyclic Sylow subgroups commute and have relatively prime orders.
Hence G≅C15.
□
Worked problem16
Show that every group of order 35 is cyclic.
Complete solution17
Let ∣G∣=35=5⋅7. Here p=7 and q=5. Since
5∤6,
the cyclic criterion for groups of order pq applies. Therefore
G≅C35.
Hence every group of order 35 is cyclic.
□
Worked problem18
Show that every group of order 77 is cyclic.
Complete solution19
Let ∣G∣=77=7⋅11. Here p=11 and q=7. Since
7∤10,
the cyclic criterion applies. Therefore
G≅C77.
Hence there is, up to isomorphism, only one group of order 77.
□
Independent practice20
Prove that every group of order 65 is cyclic.
Let G be a group of order 143. Show that its Sylow 13-subgroup and Sylow 11-subgroup are both normal.
Explain why a nonabelian group of order 21 may exist.
Answer21
Since 65=5⋅13 and 5∤12, every group of order 65 is cyclic.
We have n13≡1(mod13) and n13∣11, so n13=1. Also n11≡1(mod11) and n11∣13, so n11=1.
Since 21=3⋅7 and 3∣6, the divisibility obstruction does not rule out a nonabelian semidirect product.
Questions to consolidate
Frequently Asked Questions
3
1Why is the Sylow p-subgroup normal when p>q?
Its number must divide q and be congruent to 1 modulo p, forcing the number to be 1.
2Why does q∣(p−1) appear?
A nontrivial action of a group of order q on Cp gives an element of order q in Aut(Cp), whose order is p−1.
3Does q∣(p−1) guarantee exactly one nonabelian group?
In the basic prime-order case, it permits a nontrivial semidirect product; classification then depends on the possible actions.